Skip to content
X page opens in new windowYouTube page opens in new windowInstagram page opens in new window
ASAPbio
Accelerating Science and Publication in Biology
ASAPbio
  • Blog
    • All posts
    • ASAPbio newsUpdates and announcements from ASAPbio
    • Newsletter
    • Preprints
    • Peer review
    • Guest posts
    • News from around the web
  • Preprints
    • Preprint resource center
      • Preprints in COVID-19 research
      • Preprint FAQ
      • Preprint licensing FAQ
      • List of preprint servers: policies and practices across platforms
      • Journal policies & practices
      • Funder policies
      • University policies
      • Biology preprints over time
      • Preprint stories
      • Preprint journal clubs
    • Take action to support preprints
    • Preprints in Progress
    • Request stickers
    • Transpose: database of journal policies (external)
  • Peer review
    • ReimagineReview: registry of peer review experiments (external)
    • Preprint Reviewer Recruitment Network
    • Review Commons: journal-independent peer review platform (external)
    • #FeedbackASAP (2021 meeting)
    • Encouraging Preprint Curation and Review: A Design Sprint (2020 meeting)
    • Crowd preprint review
    • Publish your reviews!
    • FAST principles for preprint feedback
    • Understanding preprint review (video)
    • Public preprint feedback – FAQ
    • Journal review
      • Transpose: database of journal policies (external)
      • FAQ on publishing journal peer review
      • Open letter on the publication of journal peer review reports
      • Peer Review Meeting (2018)
        • Attendees
        • Agenda
        • Peer review survey results
        • Vote on transparency & recognition
        • Peer review meeting summary
        • Peer Review Commentary
  • Community
    • Fellows program
    • ASAPbio Local Hubs
    • Community Projects
    • Preprint Review Club Support
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Meetings
      • Preprint Meeting (2016)
        • Commentary for 2016 meeting
        • Survey results
        • Draft document results
        • Meeting objectives
        • Program
        • Attendees (2016 preprint meeting)
        • Videos: talks and discussions
        • Preprint Resources
          • Preprint reading
          • Different models in science communication
      • Funders’ Workshop (2016)
      • Technical Workshop (2016)
        • Agenda
        • Background
        • Attendees
      • Scientific Society Preprint Town Hall (2017)
      • Evolving Preprint Ecosystem (2017)
      • Peer Review (2018)
      • #PreprintSprint (2020)
      • #bioPreprints2020 (2020)
        • Summary blog post
        • Agenda
        • Background information from previous ASAPbio meetings
      • Preprints in the Public Eye (2020)
      • #FeedbackASAP: growing preprint review (2021)
      • Recognizing Preprint Peer Review (2022)
  • About us
    • About ASAPbio
    • ASAPbio 2024 Roadmap
    • Code of Conduct and Community participation guidelines
    • Privacy Policy
Search:
Search
  • Blog
    • All posts
    • ASAPbio newsUpdates and announcements from ASAPbio
    • Newsletter
    • Preprints
    • Peer review
    • Guest posts
    • News from around the web
  • Preprints
    • Preprint resource center
      • Preprints in COVID-19 research
      • Preprint FAQ
      • Preprint licensing FAQ
      • List of preprint servers: policies and practices across platforms
      • Journal policies & practices
      • Funder policies
      • University policies
      • Biology preprints over time
      • Preprint stories
      • Preprint journal clubs
    • Take action to support preprints
    • Preprints in Progress
    • Request stickers
    • Transpose: database of journal policies (external)
  • Peer review
    • ReimagineReview: registry of peer review experiments (external)
    • Preprint Reviewer Recruitment Network
    • Review Commons: journal-independent peer review platform (external)
    • #FeedbackASAP (2021 meeting)
    • Encouraging Preprint Curation and Review: A Design Sprint (2020 meeting)
    • Crowd preprint review
    • Publish your reviews!
    • FAST principles for preprint feedback
    • Understanding preprint review (video)
    • Public preprint feedback – FAQ
    • Journal review
      • Transpose: database of journal policies (external)
      • FAQ on publishing journal peer review
      • Open letter on the publication of journal peer review reports
      • Peer Review Meeting (2018)
        • Attendees
        • Agenda
        • Peer review survey results
        • Vote on transparency & recognition
        • Peer review meeting summary
        • Peer Review Commentary
  • Community
    • Fellows program
    • ASAPbio Local Hubs
    • Community Projects
    • Preprint Review Club Support
  • Events
    • Calendar
    • Meetings
      • Preprint Meeting (2016)
        • Commentary for 2016 meeting
        • Survey results
        • Draft document results
        • Meeting objectives
        • Program
        • Attendees (2016 preprint meeting)
        • Videos: talks and discussions
        • Preprint Resources
          • Preprint reading
          • Different models in science communication
      • Funders’ Workshop (2016)
      • Technical Workshop (2016)
        • Agenda
        • Background
        • Attendees
      • Scientific Society Preprint Town Hall (2017)
      • Evolving Preprint Ecosystem (2017)
      • Peer Review (2018)
      • #PreprintSprint (2020)
      • #bioPreprints2020 (2020)
        • Summary blog post
        • Agenda
        • Background information from previous ASAPbio meetings
      • Preprints in the Public Eye (2020)
      • #FeedbackASAP: growing preprint review (2021)
      • Recognizing Preprint Peer Review (2022)
  • About us
    • About ASAPbio
    • ASAPbio 2024 Roadmap
    • Code of Conduct and Community participation guidelines
    • Privacy Policy

Daily Archives: 2018-01-19

You are here:
  1. Home
  2. 2018
  3. January
  4. 19

Peer Feedback

Peer reviewBy Jessica Polka2018-01-197 Comments

By Ron Vale, Tony Hyman, and Jessica Polka Summary We propose the creation of a scientist-driven, journal-agnostic peer review service that produces an “Evaluated Preprint” and facilitates subsequent publication in a journal.

Creative Commons License
This work by ASAPbio is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
Go to Top