Skip to navigation menu Skip to main content Skip to footer

Keep up to date on open scholarly communication! Check out what’s new on the blog.

New to preprints and open peer review? Explore our resource library.

Get the latest and greatest preprint and open peer review news in your inbox! Sign up for our newsletter.

Interim Progress Report on a “Beyond the Article” Action Group: Learnings and Next Steps

Interim Progress Report on a “Beyond the Article” Action Group: Learnings and Next Steps

Context for moving “beyond the article”: Why we began this work

A November 2025 convening in Pisa, Italy, brought together representatives from initiatives working to change research assessment and scholarly publishing. Workshop participants agreed that changes in these two areas are interdependent, and it is not possible to reform one area without concomitant changes in the other. One of the key areas of shared interest that was identified was bolstering recognition of research outputs beyond articles.

Co-led by Felix Dijkstal (International Science Council), Anna Hatch (HHMI), and Katie Corker (ASAPbio), the action group has convened six times between March and October 2026. Other contributors to the work have included John Chodacki (California Digital Libraries), Heather Joseph (SPARC), Wolfgang Kaltenbrunner (CWTS – Leiden), Veronique Kiermer (PLOS), Damian Pattinson (eLife), and Iraxte Puebla (Make Data Count). 

What we’ve done so far and what we’ve learned

We began our work by identifying organizations and initiatives with projects that are working to move the research ecosystem beyond articles. We created a map to better understand these projects. The map classifies projects according to their organization type (infrastructure, repository, advocacy, publisher, funder, research performing organization, other), discipline (life science, social science, physics/engineering/computer science, humanities, or multiple disciplines), audience (local, regional, international), and the type of research outputs of focus (data, software and code, preprints, other single output, many outputs, all outputs). Projects are also classified by their scope and stage of development:

Scope: The part(s) of the system the initiative is primarily trying to change.

  • Discoverable (Discovery and indexing): the initiative works to ensure that non-article outputs can be found and searched online, for example by getting them listed in databases or catalogues.
  • Citable (Citation and persistent identifiers): the initiative works to ensure that non-article outputs can be formally referenced by others, for example by assigning them a permanent identifier (such as a DOI) so they can be reliably linked and credited.
  • Operationalized (Evaluation criteria and frameworks): the initiative works to ensure that non-article outputs can be meaningfully evaluated, for example by developing criteria or frameworks that reviewers, institutions, or funders can use to judge their quality and importance.
  • Recognized (Career and funding reward systems): the initiative works to ensure that non-article outputs are taken into account in decisions that directly affect researchers’ careers or funding, such as hiring, promotion, or grant allocation.

Stage of Development: How far the initiative has progressed from making a case for change to achieving it.

  • Advocacy/norm-setting: the initiative is primarily arguing that non-traditional outputs should be recognised, for example through published statements or principles. No concrete tools or practices have yet been put in place.
  • Pilot: the initiative has moved beyond making arguments and is testing an approach in practice, but only within a limited number of institutions, disciplines, or contexts.
  • Established practice: the initiative’s approach is being applied consistently and is recognised within a community or field, but has not yet been formally built into institutional or national evaluation systems.
  • Institutionalised: the initiative’s approach has been formally adopted in evaluation systems, for example in national assessment frameworks, funder requirements, or institutional promotion criteria.

Twenty-three initiatives were catalogued, surveyed, and subsequently convened in a July 2026 roundtable. Roundtable participants discussed factors that contribute to coordination challenges between different initiatives, along with what it might take to jointly address shared obstacles. Roundtable participants noted that although efforts to solve this problem have been ongoing for many years, there is renewed interest in addressing things systemically in light of disruptions and opportunities stemming from ecosystem changes due to AI/LLMs. 

Taking the map together with the roundtable discussion, we learned a few things. First, work to move research publishing beyond articles is plentiful, but not well coordinated. In particular, few projects work in a coordinated way across research assessment reform and publishing reform efforts. Second, there was a clear sense in the roundtable discussion that although individual initiatives each make the case for the need to advance their particular cause, the arguments for the need to move beyond articles at a more general level have not been made as frequently. Participants saw an opportunity to lay out the case more clearly for a broader audience.   

Moving forward and next steps

Roundtable participants recognized that reforms are needed beyond expanding the pool of research outputs that matter for researcher assessment, but agreed that our work will focus more narrowly on broadening attention to outputs beyond research articles, such as data, software/code, and protocols. The group also advised that there is an opportunity to communicate how research outputs beyond articles help address AI-driven changes in research communication that are already underway.

Consequently, the action group is jointly writing a thought piece making the case for better integration of research outputs beyond articles into research publishing and assessment systems and what this means in the AI-era. We expect this piece will be shared in early 2027. The main purpose of this thought piece is to create a space for discussion and ideation about these issues, both among the initiatives that are working to enact these reforms and beyond them.

Additionally, the action group will convene a second roundtable to discuss opportunities for joint action among initiatives that are all striving for similar changes. In the spirit of our recent piece, we believe coordination between research assessment reform and publishing reform to be essential to the success of both reform efforts. 

Initiatives that did not participate in the first roundtable are invited to join us for subsequent discussions. To join the discussion, please write to Katie Corker ([email protected]). 

0 Comments

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published or shared. Required fields are marked *.